Fare-Dodging Insurance

Public transport is the lifeblood of many great cities, but not everyone can keep up when the cost of monthly passes climbs steadily. In Berlin, where fare evasion can eventually put people behind bars, a creative solution emerged: community-based insurance funds that cover transit fines for members. This initiative is far more than just a way to dodge the system—it demonstrates ingenuity and solidarity, and has sparked a broader conversation across Europe.

The Birth and Impact of Berlin’s Fare-Dodging Funds

For decades, German law has allowed for substitute imprisonment if certain fines—such as those for riding public transport without a valid ticket—go unpaid. Each year, thousands face custodial sentences for what starts as modest penalties, with those most affected often coming from vulnerable social groups.

It was in this context that journalist and activist Arne Semsrott founded the Freiheitsfonds (“Freedom Fund”) in late 2021. The idea was remarkably straightforward: collect donations to pay the fines of those sentenced for fare evasion, thus securing their immediate release from prison. The demand was clear—within weeks, hundreds of thousands of euros were raised, and by autumn 2023, more than 850 prisoners had regained their freedom thanks to the initiative.

The story did not end there. This movement led to the creation of informal insurance collectives where people contribute a modest monthly amount, and the fund covers the occasional fare-dodging fine. By organizing in this way, Berliners are revisiting the cooperative roots of insurance and mutual aid, repositioning themselves not merely as consumers of a public service but as active shapers of urban life.

Other European Examples

Berlin’s model builds on the trail blazed by activists elsewhere. Sweden’s Planka.nu group formalized a similar insurance scheme in the early 2000s, encouraging members to ride local transit without tickets, with the organization paying fines as they arose. Over two decades, Planka.nu has kept the conversation alive about the fairness and accessibility of public transportation.

In Spain, the “Yo No Pago” (“I’m Not Paying”) movement has taken a more confrontational approach, organizing mass protests and flash mobs to oppose fare hikes and austerity measures. While their tactics differ, their core message is shared: when public services become too costly, citizens will collaborate and innovate in response.

Legal and Social Considerations

The legal status of these insurance funds remains ambiguous. German law currently allows the payment of another person’s fines; however, coordinated efforts to encourage fare evasion could attract legal scrutiny. This precarious existence only highlights their importance, prompting debates over whether transport should be accessible and affordable for all.

Why It Matters

There is a lesson here beyond fare-dodging alone. Insurance, at its core, is meant to be a tool for collectively facing risk. In Berlin and across Europe, citizens have revived this principle in a new context, pushing back against systems that sometimes leave the most vulnerable behind. These efforts are more than just clever—they invite reflection about fairness, solidarity, and whose responsibility it is to keep cities moving.

From a personal perspective, it is difficult not to admire the ingenuity at the heart of these movements. They remind us that even when confronted with rigid rules, communities can imagine creative, effective solutions that echo century-old traditions of mutual support. This spirit of collaboration and resistance, more than anything, makes cities vibrant, resilient, and surprisingly innovative.

---

Berlin’s informal fare-dodging insurance is a striking example of what happens when citizens refuse to accept the status quo and instead build alternative models—together. The result is not merely practical; it is powerful, and it may yet inspire more equitable urban futures.